A Librarian’s Personal View: Weeding — Not the Garden Kind

by Shelley Toler Franz

We’ve all seen the outraged social media posts or maybe even an article in a local newspaper: “The library is throwing away perfectly good books!” with a photo of a full dumpster of books that do, on cursory glance, look like “perfectly good books.” The thing is . . . they probably aren’t. Libraries withdraw books for numerous reasons: lack of circulation, damage, outdated information. Libraries also watch for silverfish and bedbug infestations, mold, and assorted other fun stuff that causes them to get rid of materials.

Libraries constantly rotate collections to bring patrons the newest books while balancing them with old favorites. Libraries aren’t the TARDIS, they aren’t bigger on the inside, and every library I know struggles with not having enough shelf space. Want the newest James Patterson? Well, something just sitting on the shelf that no one has read in a few years probably needs to go away to make room.

Let’s dig a little deeper into what we in the library field call “weeding.”

Unless you’re fortunate enough to work in a library that has enough staff to maintain a constant round of materials checking, and no one I personally know does, the first step may look like an overcrowded shelf, with no room to cram in another book. The shelvers complain. The patrons complain. It’s obvious something must be done. That something is to remove books, aka weeding.

The librarian runs a circulation status report, which shows how many circulations a book has had and how long it’s been on the shelf with no circulations. Depending on which area you’re weeding, that timeline can look like anything from five years with no circulations to two years with no movement. In some sections of nonfiction, it’s a little trickier, because you’re also looking to weed out outdated material. You might look for publication dates no longer than three years ago, for example, in addition to the number of circulations.

Once the circulation statistics show a book has been on the shelf for X amount of time without moving, or other weeding criteria is met, it’s time to pull it and take it to Technical Services. They withdraw it both from the local library collection software, and from OCLC—the underlying foundation of WorldCat—so it won’t show up in other databases, as if your library still owns it. This prevents someone from another library requesting an item to fill an interlibrary loan when it’s been removed. Once that’s done, policy takes over as to the next destination of the material. I can assure you, it most likely isn’t the dumpster.

Most libraries have established policies for how to dispose of weeded materials. Fortunate libraries that have the room to store books have an annual sale. Local recycling places can handle books. Other libraries donate weeded materials to care homes or assisted living facilities. Outlets such as Better World Books resell them and give the library a percentage of proceeds. Almost no library I know will ever throw a book in a dumpster, unless it’s obviously destroyed or is—how to put this delicately—a biohazard. Why? Precisely to avoid the scenario I opened with. It’s every librarian’s nightmare to have an outraged member of the public screaming at them that “The library is throwing away perfectly good books that I, as a taxpayer, paid for!”

Once the books are pulled off the shelf, then the librarian can shift things to make room for new books. Of course, this can also lead to a “But my author was right there and I could walk straight to them!” scenario once things are moved and nice and neat, but sometimes there is just no winning when you’re dealing with the public.


Shelly Franz specializes in Adult Collection Development and is the Adult Readers’ Advisory Librarian at the Dixon Public Library in Dixon, Illinois. A native Texan, the Southern drawl remains. She’s lived in the Midwest, surrounded by cornfields, for 20 years with an adoring husband and four feline hooligans.

 


 

Sign Up for WPNews

Get Two FREE ebooks!
WPNews Signup
© 2026 Writers and Publishers Network
WPN is a California 501(c)(3) nonprofit
With questions or concerns, contact webmaster@writersandpublishersnetwork.com